[Vim-l] login policy

[fREW]

On 7/16/07, hermitte at free.fr <hermitte at free.fr> wrote:
> Sebastian wrote:
> > I was on honeymoon and didn't care for the wiki since about a month ...
> > Sorry for that.
>
> Congratulations !
> (You are forgiven. ^^)
>
> > > -- a new tip has been
> > > added this week end [1] but I'm afraid nobody will ever see
> > > it as it does not respect the implicit chart of this particular
> > > wiki.
> > Sorry,  I don't understand what you mean by implicit chart?
>
> I was refering to the look and feel shared by all tip pages.
> Have a look at the initial version of that new tip.
>
>
> fREW <frioux at gmail.com> wrote:
> > I agree with Angela.  We should somehow have a reminder, like, "Are
> > you sure you don't want to log in before modifying this page?"
>
> Indeed, that could be enough.
> Angela, the link you gave us, does it apply to every pages, or only to the edit
> page?
>
> If we could have a reminder only when we are anonymous, and when we are trying
> to edit a page, that'll be nice. If the reminder could come as a magenta
> div-panel (like {{review}} one), it would be even nicier. In a perfect world, an
> anonynous user editing a *new* tip-page will see another reminder that tells him
> about {{vimtip}} and categories.
>

This reminds me, I think that our review window would be better in the
talk page, like on wikipedia.  I am not saying that we should be like
wikipedia, as it's not a wiki as much as it is an encyclopedia.  I
think that those review windows might be there for a long time and
that it would be good to not have them right on top of the tip.
Because people should be able to use the tips wiki in the meantime
even if we are still messing around with cleanup and stuff.

What do you guys think?

-- 
-fREW